This is the first post in a five-part “Flame Resistant Clothing Materials” series. Check back regularly to find out more information on the properties of common FR clothing materials, how your day-to-day cotton stacks up in comparison, and more!
Flame resistant (FR) and arc rated (AR) fabrics are used to manufacture FR clothing, which is worn by workers in many industries as the “last line of defense” against serious injury from arc flash, flash fire, molten metal, and combustible dust. These fabrics are self-extinguishing; they do not ignite and continue to burn once the heat source is removed, and they do not melt. Watch Scott Margolin, Vice President of Technical at Tyndale, explain this life-saving technology below:
All FR fibers and fabrics in common use in the USA today are engineered by people, using chemistry. While increased innovation in the industry has put more brands and compositions of FR fabric on the market than ever before, most FR fabrics fall into two categories: inherent and treated.
What are inherent FR fibers?
Inherently FR fabrics are knit or woven from fibers that have flame resistance built into their chemical structures. Interestingly, while the word inherent denotes a core property, or something that is innately and naturally a part of the whole, all inherent fibers in use today are engineered by humans. Because the FR engineering is done during creation of the fiber itself and is an inseparable part of the fiber, the flame resistance of garments manufactured from inherent fiber is permanent. Common and popular inherent fibers include aramids (Nomex®, Kevlar®, Glenguard and others), modacrylics (FRMC®, DH, DuPont MHP, Tecasafe®), and carbon fibers (Tecgen®).
What is treated FR fabric?
Treated fabric begins as a product that is flammable (typically a cotton or a cotton rich blend) and then flame retardants are engineered into the fabric to create flame resistance. There are a number of different treated technologies being used in the world today, and the best of these technologies create a flame resistant polymer inside the hollow core of the cotton fibers—producing fabrics that are guaranteed FR for the life of the garment. There are three American manufacturers whose treated FR cottons are lab and market-proven, have a guarantee with no asterisk (vs. those whose asterisk denotes laboratory laundering conditions and a 100-laundering limit), and are consistent and reliable: Mount Vernon Mills (MVM), Westex Ultrasoft®, iQ®, Indura® and True Comfort®, and PyroSafe by Antex®.
How does the chemistry of FR fabric work?
To understand FR fabric engineering, it is first important to understand fire. Fire is the product of a chemical reaction requiring heat, fuel, and oxygen. All FR fabrics (inherent and treated) are engineered to remove or reduce the presence of one or more of those components by interrupting the combustion process. Combustion is the chain reaction of heat breaking down material into fuel, which reacts with oxygen to create more heat, breaking down the material into more fuel, and so on. Depending on the type of FR fabric, this process can be interrupted by removing the fuel source, removing heat from impacting the fabric, or displacing oxygen. Most common FR fabrics char instead of burning, which acts to both remove fuel and block heat, and modacrylic fabrics also contain an active process that displaces oxygen. While the science of combustion and FR fabric is highly technical, understanding the properties of fire can provide the building blocks for greater insight into FR fabric technologies.
How are inherent and treated FR technologies different?
There are multiple technologies of inherent fibers, and each uses a different process to create flame resistant fabric. Some inherent fibers, like modacrylic, use a gas-phase technology. Gas-state technologies extinguish flame by forming a type of molecule called a free radical oxygen scavenger in the gas layer above the fabric and suffocating the fire, preventing further decomposition and creation of fuel. Other inherent fibers, such as aramids, are thermally stable and act in the solid phase—meaning their molecular structure resists decomposition to high temperatures, then forms a friable char. This interrupts combustion by preventing the creation of fuel.
Most modern types of treated FR fabric also act in the solid phase, causing the fabric to char instead of burning when exposed to heat—reducing the amount of fuel available and extinguishing the fire.
With the drastic improvements and innovations made in FR engineering over the years, differences between the durability of flame resistance and protective qualities of inherent and treated fabrics have essentially disappeared, at least among the major US manufacturers. A worker wearing FR clothing made from inherent or quality treated fabric will be well protected for the life of the garment. And, home laundering is easier than ever, as manufacturer recommendations are the same for both inherent and treated garments—no liquid chlorine bleach and no fabric softener.
Nowadays, choosing between the two types of fabric most often comes down to worker preference—namely comfort, durability of the garment, and value.
Want to learn more? Browse our blog posts for more helpful information about FR fabrics and the answers to other frequently-asked questions. Plus, find out about FR product options and how our managed program can help you maximize compliance and protection while enhancing service and satisfaction.
Have additional questions? Schedule a complimentary 15-minute technical session with Scott Margolin, Tyndale’s Vice President of Technical. Simply complete the form below and Scott will contact you at a mutually agreeable time to speak one-on-one.